So who really was negatively impacted by the recent recession? Media outlets would have you believe that there was massive "carnage" throughout the private sector, and teachers, having escaped unharmed, need to stop "whining" and "give back."
But are these claims true?
Lets take a look at a few pieces of evidence from Statistics Canada:
The above chart reveals that most of the job losses during the "recession" were in low paying private sector jobs. There was little job loss in typical professions. Moreover, most of the individuals who made less than $10.00 per hour were in the age range of 15-24, that is, people just starting their careers, not people who were in them.
But there is more:
So not only was most of the job loss incurred by those who were 15-24 in age and just getting started in their careers, but those who were 15-24 in age and lacking a University Degree (7.2% vs 0.6% in men and 2.7% vs 1.2% in women).
Since most professionals between the ages of 25-65 did not suffer as we have been led to believe, taking away a teachers right to collectively bargain because of the "massive carnage" is not a factual argument.
Nor is the argument that individuals were forced to take wage cuts, and thus, teachers should as well. As the statistics show there was actually an increase in jobs paying $40 or more per hour during this period (12.9%).